The Wrong Fix for Social Security | Ben Ritz

2 hours ago 1

Rommie Analytics

About the guest

Ben Ritz is Vice President of Policy Development for the Progressive Policy Institute.

Social Security’s trust fund is projected to run dry by 2032, which means across-the-board benefit cuts of about 22 percent if Congress fails to act. 

Bipartisan sentiment has coalesced around the idea of raising or ending the income cap on payroll taxes, currently set at $184,500, to put the program back on the path to solvency. In an op-ed for The New York Times, Ohio’s Republican Senator Bernie Moreno and Massachusetts Democratic Senator Elizabeth Warren proposed eliminating the cap altogether, which they said could raise about $3 trillion over 10 years. 

The Progressive Policy Institute’s Ben Ritz argues that this proposal has serious flaws, however, and will not accomplish its goals.

From the conversation

If you were to keep the program as it is, not make a fundamental change to the benefit structure and just eliminate the taxable maximum, you are giving higher benefits to the people who need them least in retirement. And that is going to be paid by a permanently higher tax burden on working Americans. 

Ben Ritz, progressive Policy Institute

Read the transcript

Edited for length and clarity.

Part 1: Social Security’s broken finances

Anne Kim: If Congress does nothing, Social Security’s trust fund is scheduled to go broke by 2032. What does that mean for people’s benefits? Like my mom, [or] your grandma?

Ben Ritz: The way Social Security works is we use payroll taxes from workers to fund benefits for current retirees. We have the trust fund to basically keep track of past years when there were surpluses. Now we’re running deficits, and when that trust fund runs out of money, we can only pay what is payable with current revenues. That’s going to mean an automatic cut benefit cut of about a quarter when that happens.

Anne Kim: A quarter. Wow. 

Ben Ritz: It’s somewhere between 20 and 25 percent, and it grows over time.

Anne Kim: Gotcha. Let’s go into a little bit more detail about how Social Security is financed, just so people really understand. All of us and our employers both pay Social Security taxes, right? It’s that number that shows up on our pay stubs as FICA payroll taxes, and that’s about 12.5 percent of wages for Social Security, all told, and Medicare taxes are on top of that.

But the taxes only apply up to a certain level of income. So when you hit the payroll tax cap, which is $184,500, you’re not taxed on the income above that, which sounds regressive and unfair. And that’s why some members of Congress have said, well, here’s an easy way to fix Social Security: Get rid of the cap. So can you explain the logic behind that proposal before we get into the problems?

Ben Ritz: You laid it out. Right now, people who are lower income are paying a higher percentage of their wages into Social Security than people who are higher income. I think that those regressivity arguments do have some merit, and that’s why there are proposals to uncap it. What a lot of people don’t think about is the reason it was capped—because the benefits people get are based on how much they pay into the program. So, yes, Elon Musk is not paying taxes on all his income towards Social Security, but he’s also not getting benefits that are designed to replace all his income. Whereas somebody who is earning below the cap, they’re getting credit for Social Security benefits off of every dollar they earn, off of every dollar they’re paying taxes on.

Part 2: Raising the income cap on Social Security taxes: A critique

Anne Kim: That’s interesting. There was a New York Times op-ed recently, and it was a bipartisan op-ed by Senator Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts and Bernie Moreno of Ohio. They made this point: Why should a middle-class nurse pay a larger share of her paycheck than a wealthy corporate lawyer? It’s kind of hard to argue against that.

Ben Ritz: Right. And the reason is because the nurse was the example. The nurse is getting a bigger share of her income replaced by Social Security than the wealthy corporate lawyer. That’s how the program was designed. We can take issues with that, as far as whether that’s the way it should operate, but that was always the design of it.

Anne Kim: Let’s walk through your critique. And it’s not just the Warren-Moreno plan, right? It’s an idea that’s been floating around for a while. 

So in their op-ed, Senators Warren and Moreno say that eliminating the payroll tax cap would raise $3 trillion over ten years, which sounds like a lot of money, but is that enough to save Social Security?

Ben Ritz: No, it’s not. If we were to eliminate the tax cap and provide no additional benefit credit for Elon Musk or the corporate lawyer…

Anne Kim: What’s the benefit credit? Can you explain that?

Ben Ritz: Sure. That goes back to what I was giving in my earlier answer about how we give people higher benefits when they pay higher taxes. So you could eliminate the payroll tax cap and give benefit credit. And if you did that, it would close less than half of the current Social Security gap. And the share of the gap that it would close declines over time because initially you’re collecting more in taxes from the higher earners, and you don’t pay out the higher benefits until they retire. So the costs grow over time with the benefit. If you weren’t giving any benefit credit, you could close about two-thirds of the gap, but it still isn’t enough to save the program.

Anne Kim: Just to make it clear, how the benefit credit would work is if you’re making a million dollars, then the amount you would get from Social Security would be significantly higher, say, than what you’re getting now. So it just means that you’d have to raise even more revenue to pay those benefits. Got it. So that’s critique number one. Now you also make the argument in your piece that eliminating the payroll tax cap basically amounts to a tax hike on the wealthy that’s too big to make sense. There’s a huge amount of sentiment right now for taxing the crap out of billionaires. What do you mean that this tax hike is too big to make sense? 

Ben Ritz: So before I answer that question, I just want to just make clear that I think what we covered in the last answer was two critiques. One is that it’s not enough to solve the problem. And the second, which we didn’t really talk about, which was implicit, but I want to make it explicit, is that if you were to keep the program as it is, not make a fundamental change to the benefit structure and just eliminate the taxable maximum, you are giving higher benefits to the people who need them least in retirement. And that is going to be paid by a permanently higher tax burden on working Americans. 

I think it’s worth just really emphasizing this. So those are the two first two critiques. The third one, I also want to clarify: I didn’t say that it is too big of a tax increase on the wealthy to make sense. I’ve argued for a tax increase of this level in the context of a comprehensive budget plan, but I think it would be so big that you couldn’t then raise taxes on the rich for much else. 

And I think putting all that money into Social Security when we have bigger issues in Medicare and the broader federal budget would not be a good use of those limited funds. And why do we think it would be a limited amount? Because if you eliminate the Social Security tax max, that is raising the top federal tax rate on incomes to over 50 percent.

That means we’re taking more than half of every dollar that somebody earns over a certain level and giving it to the federal government. And that’s before state income taxes. You put state income taxes on there, and some people working in some places would be paying a tax rate that is above what is widely considered to be the revenue-maximizing level, which means if you raise taxes above that rate, you would probably be losing revenue. Tapping out all our tax-the-rich fiscal capacity just to keep paying higher benefits to higher earners doesn’t make a whole lot of sense.

Part 3: How big a tax hike is too big?

Anne Kim: If I could unpack what you’re arguing there, you’re saying a couple things. Number one, if we do nothing but increase the payroll tax cap, what you’re doing is crowding out our capacity to raise taxes more broadly on the “wealthy” to fund other things that the federal government should be funding. So that’s argument number one. But then what you also seem to be arguing is that once taxes get to a certain level, you’re creating perverse incentives. Correct me if I’m wrong, but people are going to be looking for ways to evade paying these taxes. Or maybe they’ll all move to Ireland, or they’ll be doing other things that will make it difficult to collect some of this revenue that the government is counting on.

Ben Ritz: They’ll do evasion and avoidance for sure, but I think we underappreciate the degree to which it just encourages people to work less. I think there’s been this Republican argument for a long time about our current tax system that if you tax the rich too highly, they’ll just stop working because there’s no incentive. And at current tax levels, the difference between a 37 percent top rate and a 39 percent top rate, I think that’s ridiculous. I think there is more tax capacity there.

But every economist agrees that at some point between zero and 100 percent, if you’re taxing 100 percent of somebody’s labor, they are not going to work anymore. And so it’s just a question of when we cross that threshold where we’re discouraging more earnings than we’re taxing more earnings. And I think eliminating the payroll tax cap basically puts us there.

Anne Kim: Let’s get back to this idea of the benefit structure then. Just for fun, let’s talk about the idea of means testing benefits, because that’s been something else that’s been floating out there as a solution. There is no reason that somebody as rich as Donald Trump or Elon Musk, whom you mentioned, should be eligible for Social Security benefits at all when the poverty rate for seniors is 15 percent. So if we means test it, if we reduce benefits for wealthier seniors enough, is that going to be enough by itself to make the system solvent?

Ben Ritz: No, so means testing also wouldn’t be enough. And two quick points on that. One, just to clarify, I think the more comprehensive poverty rate for seniors is closer to six percent for seniors. I think that’s important.

But we’ll put that point aside for a second.

Why do we not talk about means testing? It’s a policy choice. And that policy choice is we say Social Security is supposed to be an earned benefit program. What you get out is based on what you have contributed. But if we say, except for rich people, there is a lot of concern from a lot of folks that you can no longer say that it is an earned benefit. 

Part 4: An alternative plan for reform

Anne Kim: Okay, so now we come to your solution. You’ve proposed that we should be rewarding benefits based on the number of years worked versus someone’s salary. So explain how that would work and how that’s different from what we do now.

Ben Ritz: Right now we provide a greater benefit based on how much somebody pays in each year—how much they earn. And the effect of that is we are giving the biggest benefits to the people who need them least. The corporate lawyer, even though they are getting a smaller share of their income replaced than the nurse, they are getting a bigger absolute benefit.

And when you have a pay-as-you-go system, which we do, some people think that their Social Security taxes are put in their own personal account. It’s not. We are taxing today’s workers to pay the benefits of current beneficiaries. And so we are taxing working Americans to give a bigger benefit to a retired corporate lawyer. I don’t think that system makes sense, especially when we have all these fiscal pressures. 

At the same time, we want to preserve that earned benefit paradigm that is so popular. And so our idea here is: Rather than have the benefit be based on what somebody earns, have it be based on how many years they work so that we can give a flat credit for each year worked to the nurse and the lawyer. And if they work the same number of years, they get the same benefit. If the nurse works longer, they get a higher benefit. But we think this is pro-work and makes the program more progressive.

Anne Kim: The way that you have it structured—would that be enough to save Social Security if we only do that one change? Or would we also have to do some other stuff on the revenue side?

Ben Ritz: We would also have to do some other stuff on the revenue side. Well, okay, I’ll put the asterisk up there that if you make the credit per year of work low enough, you could mathematically fix it all on the benefit side. Our proposal here was to do this as one of many reforms in a comprehensive package.

Anne Kim: Are there a couple other top-line reforms that you would offer up as part of this package that would be necessary to get Social Security solvent?

Ben Ritz: Since you mentioned the revenue side, I think it’s important to talk about that here, which is all of those issues that we talked about before with uncapping the payroll tax, both in terms of reaching a revenue-maximizing tax rate and raising these thorny benefit questions, whether you’re providing benefit credit to the rich. We think one of the key benefits of our reform here is that we’re able to delink those questions. We are able to say this is an earned benefit and have that not be based on the regressive payroll tax structure. And so now we can look at raising more revenue in a way that is a progressive tax that doesn’t have those necessary drawbacks. 

We wouldn’t just raise the payroll tax rate or scrap the payroll tax cap. We would do a comprehensive reform of our combined payroll tax and income tax system to raise more revenue and be more progressive.

Anne Kim: Interesting. So there’s one potential concern I just want to raise about your plan, and that’s its potential impact on women, right? So under the current system, women earn less than men, so their benefits tend to be smaller. But under your proposal it could still have the same effect because women also work fewer years than men because they take time out of the workforce for caregiving responsibilities, that kind of thing. And in fact, I found some Labor Department data finding that women spend about twice as much time out of the workforce as men. And there’s also a little bit of evidence that career length varies by race. There was a University of Michigan study I found concluding that Black workers, for instance, are more likely to retire early because of disability and the greater likelihood that they’re in hazardous careers. So if you’re willing to tweak your proposal a little bit in some ways to compensate for these disparities, I think I’d be all in.

Ben Ritz: One key part of our proposal is that among our other benefit reforms, we provide benefit credit for up to five years out of the labor force for caregiving. So we allow you to have five years that count as work credits, which is something that the current system just doesn’t have. That means that our proposal does more for women. On the race issue, I take your point about people of color needing to work fewer years or leave the workforce earlier, but they also tend to have lower wages and so a flattening and increased progressivity of the benefit accounts for that.

I’ll have to double-check the modeling, but my recollection is that the disparity between men and women would shrink as a result of this proposal if the whole package was enacted. It wouldn’t grow. So it’s not even mitigating a harm we would create. We are mitigating a harm in the current system. 

Part 5: If Congress fails to act

Anne Kim: Remind us of the long-term stakes if we do not figure this out. Now you have mentioned that we face, you know, at least a 22 percent benefit cut across the board in 2032, but what happens after that?

Ben Ritz: The gap between revenue and spending is growing over time, so the cut will get deeper. I think it might get as high as 30 percent, depending on the assumptions you use. 

Obviously, that just makes the situation harder. It’s more unpredictability for retirees. And I think there’s also the growing risk of a debt crisis. It’s important to clarify that this is a trade-off. If we allow the benefit cut to happen, we don’t really have a risk of a debt crisis, because we’ve brought revenue and spending and Social Security into alignment. 

A big part of future debt projections is assuming that we’re going to continue paying current benefits. The flip side is if we “fix this” by just plugging it with more borrowed money in the years until the trust fund runs out, that is likely to spark a debt crisis at a time when our debt as a percentage of economic output is higher than it’s been since World War II. It’s about to break the all-time record. Bond markets are already showing skittishness from a lot of Trump policies. I think we’re going to see that tension ratchet up. And if we don’t deal with this correctly, we could see the consequences be a whole lot worse for consumers.

More Episodes

The post The Wrong Fix for Social Security | Ben Ritz appeared first on Washington Monthly.

Read Entire Article