Ask someone if they feel like they matter, and the answer that comes back often no, or not anymore. Jennifer Wallace has been asking that question for eight years, and what she found is that we have the whole thing backward. The people who feel it least are often the ones everyone depends on most. So, what’s going on there?
Jennifer Wallace is a journalist and researcher, and the author of two instant New York Times bestsellers, Never Enough and, most recently, Mattering: The Secret to a Life of Deep Connection and Purpose. She founded The Mattering Institute and writes for The Wall Street Journal and The Washington Post. She has spent the better part of a decade studying a human need that researchers have tracked since the 1980s, and most of us have never heard named, which makes this conversation land hardest for anyone in the stretch of life where the roles that used to define you are quietly changing shape.
The question Jennifer has put to hundreds of people over eight years, and the single answer she hears more than any other Why a jar of candy brought a man to tears in the same room where he had just been handed an award What a fire chief in South Carolina built after realizing his crew almost never learns whether the people they pull from wrecked cars survive The four ingredients of mattering, validated by Gallup, and how to spot the one that has gone missing in your own life A thirty-second practice Jennifer runs before she falls asleep, and a different one she runs while brushing her teethIf you have ever been needed by everyone in your life and still felt strangely unseen, this conversation gives that feeling a name, a cause, and a first step you can take before you go to bed tonight.
You can find Jennifer at: Website | Instagram | Episode Transcript
Check out our sponsors and resources: Visit Our Sponsor Page
photo credit: Jo Bryan
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Episode Transcript:
Jonathan Fields: [00:00:00] Question do you feel like you matter not because of your title or your bank account, or what you got done today, or status or the legacy that you’re building, but more simply, just for who you are deep down? For a lot of us, the honest answer is no or not enough. Or maybe not in a really long time. Our guest today is award winning journalist and author of the book Mattering Jennifer Wallace. And she spent eight years asking people one question. Do you feel like you matter? A college student told her she only mattered when her weight was low and her GPA was high. A retired person, the guy said the hardest part of aging is that people just stop relying on you. And so many of us in the middle years of our lives, we feel needed by everyone, yet strangely invisible to ourselves. Like we really just don’t matter. We explore what mattering really is, why it’s one of our deepest human drives, how it gets wired into childhood, and why we often confuse being needed with mattering and how they’re really not the same. We also look at what happens when work or kids, or a role that we build our identity around suddenly falls away, and how that affects our sense of mattering.
Jonathan Fields: [00:01:11] Jennifer also reveals the four core ingredients of mattering, a framework validated by Gallup. And we walk through all four one by one, and also how to use them with your kids, your aging parents, your team and yourself and so many others. And before we’re done, she shares the one tiny action that she says can put anyone back on the path to mattering starting tomorrow. It costs nothing and takes only a few seconds. So excited to share this conversation with you. I’m Jonathan Fields and this is Good Life Project, and we’ll dive right in after this short break. Your recent focus has been something I have been deeply fascinated by for many years, and you’ve gone so much deeper into it than the sort of like surface level that I have. I’ve done a lot of thinking about it. You have done a lot of deep work around this topic of mattering. You literally spent years asking people a question. Do you feel like you matter? Tell me about this.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:02:14] Yeah, this was it started, um, about eight years ago, uh, when I started researching my first book. And it’s one question that I would always ask people in a gentle way, not abruptly, sort of in the middle of a conversation, you know, do you feel like you matter? And for so many people, the answer was no or not anymore. I remember I interviewed a college student who said she felt like she only mattered when her weight was low and her GPA was high. I, um, I interviewed an elderly gentleman who had long retired and was saying that the hardest part of aging is that people stop investing and relying on you. That they think you are somehow less capable than you used to be. I’ve spoken with people in middle age who feel like they matter too much at home as a parent to their aging parents, as an employee, that they just they’re spilling over with the sense of feeling needed by everybody else, but their own needs going unmet. So, um, it was a through line. I remember speaking with Gordon Flett, who is a leading researcher on mattering in Canada, and he said to me, if you want to know somebody, well, find out if they feel like they matter. If they felt like they mattered as a child to their families, to their friends, if they feel like they met her at work in their neighborhood, it’s very telling. I just want to say, if anybody out there is feeling like they don’t matter, uh, that they, they’re just one action away from getting back on that mattering path again.
Jonathan Fields: [00:03:57] I’m glad you teed that up in the beginning, because there probably are some people who are thinking immediately, I don’t think I do, or I haven’t had that feeling in a really long time. But and we’re going to get a lot deeper into that. But I’m so curious because when you teed this up by saying like, I kind of asked in a way that was, you know, like socially appropriate, right? Because this can be a very abrasive question if you just go up to somebody like, hey, so do you feel like you matter at all? Like, does your life matter? That is, that is not an easy thing for a lot of people, especially if their answer is no. So how do you even go about teeing this up in a way where you get people to drop the shields and just be open and honest?
Jennifer Wallace: [00:04:39] It would be part of a longer conversation. Um, they would, you know, it was most of the people that I was interviewing were for my books. And so I would explain to them what I’m, what I’m working on and, um, you know, would love their perspective would explain what mattering is. I think we all think we know what mattering is. We use that word all the time. But I think what most people don’t know is that it is a universal human need that researchers have been studying since the 1980s. And I define it the way they define it as feeling valued for who you are, deep at your core by your family, your friends, your colleagues, your neighbors, your community. And then having a chance to add that value back across those domains. So I, I would explain to people what mattering is. And then I would say, you know, do you feel like you matter? And, um, people, it’s so fascinating to me. So I’ve been a journalist now for 30 years. I have yet to meet someone in all of my years as a journalist who didn’t want to talk about their story, who didn’t want to try to make sense of what they had gone through. Kelly Corrigan, who is a friend of mine, talks about the follow up question and people crave the follow up question. I mean, if you want to feel like you matter and make somebody else feel like they matter, ask a follow up. Pay attention. So just by paying attention and and really authentically wanting to know their answer, people were so open with me. The conversations I have had over the last at least decades since I’ve been talking about mattering, have really changed my life. Mhm.
Jonathan Fields: [00:06:24] I want to dig into what you just shared, though. You shared this sort of like a cursory way, like the way that you define mattering. And this comes from, from my recollection, um, from, uh, Isaac Prilleltensky, who is sadly no longer with us. We have had the great pleasure of having him in conversation a few years ago. But, you know, he was this seminal researcher in the field of mattering for I think it was decades. Right? Take me deeper into that definition, though, because there are these two parts, and I think some people may kind of hear it and say, well, like, how is one different than the other?
Jennifer Wallace: [00:06:58] Right? So feeling valued the way I’ve come to think of it. And Isaac was just to, you know, press on that for a minute, an extraordinary human, extraordinary, huge, big thinker. Uh, what I would say a systems thinker, thinking about the systems beyond the one individual and just so much heart and so much humor. So he is very, very missed. The way that I think about the definition of mattering is feeling valued for who you are deep inside. So away from your accomplishments, away from your profession, away from how you look, away from what you do. Just this idea that you are inherently valuable for who you are deep inside and you want to feel that for yourself. You want to feel valued by yourself, by your family, your friends, your colleagues. You want to feel valued. But that’s only half of the equation of mattering. The other half is adding value and having a purposeful life. And also having people in your life that are helping you connect to your impact. So the way I think about mattering and the way Isaac talked about mattering is that when you feel valued, you feel more empowered to add value. And the more you add value, the more you feel valued. So it becomes this virtuous cycle that keeps feeding itself. Now, unfortunately, mattering is double edged, meaning it’s protective when you feel it and destructive when you don’t. And so when you don’t feel like you matter, you often pull back, disengage, and you are less likely to contribute, you are less likely to connect with people because you yourself are trying to protect what little you have. And so you don’t want to be vulnerable and put yourself out there adding value. So when you don’t feel valued, it becomes this vicious cycle where you don’t add value. And the more you’re not adding value, the more you’re not feeling valued. And it can be hard to break out of.
Jonathan Fields: [00:09:10] And that all makes sense to me. I want to really, I kind of hate the phrase double tap, but I want to make this so crystal clear. Can we get granular with, say, an example of each of the virtuous and the vicious cycle? So people really can wrap their heads around these two parts.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:09:28] Yeah. So feeling valued is it happens in life’s small moments. So I’ll give you a little story. I was giving a keynote at a national conference and a gentleman was getting an award from his colleagues and it was a very proud moment. They were reading off a list of accomplishments. But what brought tears to his eyes was what they did after they gave him the award. And that was reaching down and picking up a gigantic jar of M&Ms. Because those M&Ms said something the award couldn’t, it said. You are known by us. You are valued, quirks and all. And they gave him the eminence because that was his favorite snack. Um, so it feeling valued is feeling known. So in that moment, what was bringing tears to his eyes was feeling valued by his colleagues. It happens in the smallest of moments. It’s a neighbor coming by with a pot of soup when you were sick, or a colleague checking in after a hard day at work. We crave as humans to matter in the every day. I’ve come to think of it as mattering in the mundane, the details of our lives, and then having a chance to add value to the world is not some, you know, purpose with a capital P.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:10:42] I think that really trips us up. This whole idea that we all need to have a purpose with a capital P, what I’ve heard in the hundreds of conversations that I’ve now had with people about mattering is that the people that really felt like they were adding value had a kind of formula for it. They looked for a need in their community, in their school, in their workplace. And then they used what I call the three T’s, their time, their talent, their treasure to meet that need. So adding value could be in the smallest of ways. It could be knocking on the door of an elderly neighbor and saying, hey, I’m heading to Costco. Can I get you anything? Or it could be a teenager who knows that their grandmother is a recent widow. This is happening in my family right now. My dad passed away a year ago, and my 16 year old son calls her every day for 30 minutes and just he he feels valued. She feels valued, he knows he’s adding value and she is adding value to him as well.
Jonathan Fields: [00:11:52] That’s beautiful. You you said something in there also that I don’t want to to miss. Um, that feeling valued relates to feeling known. And I love that also because and you proceed to that by saying it’s not so much what you do, it’s who you are. And those all relate, right? Because I think a lot of us feel like we need to show up. We need to create some sort of action to feel valued by others. And the invitation that that if I’m getting this right that you’re making is, well, well, sure, maybe that helps. And maybe that’s part of the second part of the equation. Like maybe the things you do add value, but it doesn’t have to be that. It can be just who you are in a room, in a conversation. You know, it can be the quality of presence that you bring to the simplest passing moment. And I love that invitation because the it makes it accessible to anybody.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:12:54] It is so true. My, my dad, who passed away a year ago, died of complications from Parkinson’s. And there was a point towards the end where he was feeling, you know, he was someone who always added so much value. He was always the first one to run errands for us to watch the kids to, you know, our whole lives. He was adding value. And there was a time when he said to me, I’m sorry that I’m I forget what he said, but it was almost like, I’m sorry. It’s it’s all so much trouble these days now with me. And I said, oh my goodness, dad. I said, the opposite of trouble. I said, just sitting with you and being with you. And like you said, the attention that he was able to give to me and to everybody around him, he added such value that way. But of course, we live in a society that tells us lies about what makes us valuable. I mean, there’s, um, the great Dutch theologian Henri Nouwen talked about the three great lies of our society. I am what I have, I am what I do, and I am what people say and think about me. And those are the lies that even if we’re not aware we are ingesting, we are internalizing those lies. And it’s why, you know, we have productivity culture. It’s why, uh, there’s hyper, you know, materialism these days because we’re, we’re clamoring for what I would call the fool’s gold of mattering that that is not true mattering. True mattering is inherent.
Jonathan Fields: [00:14:28] Yeah. I love it also because there may be folks joining us. Maybe you’re just in a window right now where you’re struggling a lot. Um, you know, maybe you’re not well resourced, just emotionally, psychologically or literal external resources. And part of what you’re struggling with is just is a mattering deficit. Like, I just feel like I don’t matter to myself, to anyone, to the world. And, but I’m at a point where I’ve got nothing to give. Like I don’t have the energy to get out of bed. Like, how do I, I don’t have money. I don’t have resources. I don’t have exceptional skills that I can give to someone else. And that person is probably saying, well, I’m excluded from this. And what you’re saying is, no.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:15:13] Not at all. I love to say to people that you are one action away from feeling like you matter again. Uh, I was giving a talk at a company and a gentleman in his late 20s said to me, do you have a mantra that I could say to myself on those days, in the weeks when I feel like I do not matter? And I said, I have something better than a mantra. I said, the next time you’re feeling like that, go down to the cafeteria and thank the gentleman or the woman or the person that hands you your food with a smile and with warmth and say to them, you know, the world is so cold these days, but I just want you to know your smile provides so much warmth. You really turn my day around. Again, the fastest way to feel like you matter is to remind someone else why they do. And we can all do that. You can do that in the pharmacy. I mean, I find myself I was on a flight yesterday and, uh, you know, people were crabby. It was the flight was delayed, passengers were in a bad mood. And the, um, flight attendant was asking for somebody’s order, and he was not making eye contact with her. He was keeping his head down on his phone. And she said to him, you know, do you not even have basic respect? It was like a real moment on the plane that you could even look at me. And again, he he continued to disrespect her. And so when she came to my chair, I said to her, just smile. Keep your gorgeous smile going. I said, somebody’s having a bad day, but you don’t have to absorb it. Anyway, she and I became like fast friends on the flight, so that’s an easy way, right? To just meet someone where they are and say, I see you. I see what’s happening to you. I’m aware and, and you are more valuable than that. So you can do that. You can do that anywhere.
Jonathan Fields: [00:17:04] Yeah, I love that. Um, I knew somebody who years ago, um, it was a big flyer and every time this person would get on a flight in the airport, they would buy a sort of like a family sized bag of M&Ms and walk in and give it to whoever the, the, the head attendant was and say, I think the work you do. I know this is so hard. Um, I just wanted to thank you and like, please share this with the crew.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:17:33] So lovely. How lovely is that? So that makes you feel like you matter when you see the smile. It’s a small way of mattering.
Jonathan Fields: [00:17:42] And we’ll be right back after a word from our sponsors. So mattering makes us feel good, right? And I think we all have felt that. Like we felt those moments, those sort of like those little pings of like, ooh, like this, this feels yummy. It feels good. I want more of this. Beyond that, why is this really important to us and for us?
Jennifer Wallace: [00:18:06] So, you know, researchers who study it and I, I agree with them say that after that, it’s, it’s part of our evolutionary inheritance. So, you know, to be valued by the group to our earliest ancestors meant protection and survival, and being not valued by the group meant being isolated and certain death. And so we are still wired through evolution to to crave, to be motivated to matter. And after the drive for food and shelter, it is this motivation to matter that drives human behavior, for better or for worse. So when we feel like we matter, we show up, we engage, we contribute. When we don’t, we withdraw. We might turn to substances or self-harm to try to alleviate the pain. Some people lash out in anger as a desperate attempt to say, oh, I don’t matter. I’ll show you I matter. I think about things like school, you know, school shootings. I think about road rage, online attacks, incivility as desperate attempts for people to say, I’ll show you I matter. And I do fear that it’s about to get worse. This is as we talk about AI, I, you know, I write about this study in the book of suicidal men and the two words they most often use to describe their suffering was useless and worthless. Those are the words of feeling like you do not matter. And as Bill gates and others are tech leaders are pointing out, that, you know, within a few years, humans may not be required for most tasks. What does that mean for us? Um, we talk about universal basic income. Probably necessary, but not sufficient. We are humans that need to matter. So we need we will need to protect this need to matter in the future.
Jonathan Fields: [00:20:06] Yeah. I mean, I think when you start to play it out in the context of tech and AI, but you start to see potential handwriting on the wall and potential paths diverging in different directions. And there is this subtler conversation, which is like we have certain fundamental human needs, you know, and core to that is the need to matter. And if a lot of that has been derived from like what we do in the world then, and a lot of what we do becomes replaced. What do we do with that?
Jennifer Wallace: [00:20:41] I think we don’t know what the future is going to bring. I have a hopeful response, um, that that if AI serves humanity in a way that we hope serves humanity, that we will have more time in our lives to be the interdependent humans that we were created to be. And that means relying on our neighbors and our neighbors relying on us. I think a lot of why people today feel like they don’t matter is because we have so much coming at us all day long. We have the news, we have texts, we have slack, we have deadlines and so much output being demanded of us that just to get through our to do list, just to get through our days, we often have to put our heads down and just go through life on autopilot. And when we do that, we miss the signals that others are sending to us. That we matter. We miss the warmth, the smile, the thank you. And we miss pointing out to people our appreciation for who they are and how they matter to us. My husband and I took a trip 25 years ago through France, and I was the navigator, and I’m a horrible navigator, and I was so stressed out reading the maps. And, you know, the whole trip was me figuring out where to go, where to get gas, where to stop for a bathroom break. And then 25 years later, we went on this same trip and we had up Google Maps. And so we plugged in the destination and we were able to have the most extraordinary conversation. We had this deep conversation that was not available to us 25 years ago because I was stressed out on the map. So what I’m hoping with AI is that it opens us up to having more time to build those relationships, to be interdependent, to enjoy each other as humans. You know, something that we’ve been, for a variety of reasons pulled away from?
Jonathan Fields: [00:22:42] Yeah, I love that. And I’m nodding along in part because the call it a crisis of mattering. It’s not new. This has been a part. I mean, we have people who are wildly productive, who are incredibly accomplished, who are capitalists, successful according to society’s definition of productivity and accumulation and status and all the stuff that we measure life by. And yet, you know, they do, they do, they do, they amass, they amass, they amass everything that was on the list. They’ve checked or they’re on their way to checking. And yet, if you ask them like, how’s your life? Do you like, does do you matter? Does what you do matter? Like they’ll say no and they’ll be suffering inside. So I love your sort of like reframe that says, well, okay, so all the things that we thought were going to give us the feeling actually, for the most part, haven’t. So if we can offload a lot of those things and then shift our focus maybe back to the smaller, maybe relational, maybe just day to day human things that we actually know through science do. Maybe that’s a good thing.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:23:53] I totally agree with you. I totally agree with you. And, and that’s the hopeful path. But we are going to have to be really careful to stay on that path.
Jonathan Fields: [00:24:02] Yeah for sure. You brought up the P word earlier in our conversation purpose. Oftentimes, you know, sort of like relatively standard advice is if you feel empty, go find your purpose. You know, this has been a part of popular psychology, self-help, influencer culture or creator culture, um, for a long time. You found people doing obviously meaningful, purposeful work who are burning out, who are disenchanted, disenfranchised anyway. Tease out a little bit more the relationship between purpose and mattering.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:24:42] So I, for the book, I went in search of people who worked in careers where you just had to know they mattered. Like they just, there’s no way they couldn’t know they mattered. And I, I started with firefighters. I was like, you know, they’re, they’re rushing into burning buildings, saving lives. Of course they know they matter. And then I met a fire chief named Greg in North Charleston, South Carolina. Um, who was telling me that even firefighters can struggle to see the impact of their work. Um, and he explained it with a story that when he was a rookie, he and his crew were called to a car wreck where they, a woman, a young woman, was trapped. And Greg went into the car to shield her from the glass as they worked to free her. They got her out and EMS took over and she was rushed to the hospital and Greg and his crew were left packing up and never knowing what happened next. Did the woman survive? Did she ever walk again? Did their efforts that night make a difference? And so it surprised me to know that that firefighters rarely hear about the outcomes of their rescues. They’re often the first to arrive at the scene of a car accident or a medical emergency. They stabilize the person, um, before EMS takes over. And so they are always disconnected from their impact. They don’t know what you know, if they’re purposeful, work actually made an impact. And so what Greg did is something we can all do. He created a system to track the outcomes of rescues so that his firefighters would know when their actions had saved a life or ease someone’s suffering.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:26:28] Because it’s not enough to do meaningful work. We need to know that work makes a difference and that it matters. In an ideal world, we would be connected to our impact by our family and our friends and our colleagues. In an ideal world, we would offer advice and someone would circle back and say, hey, I took your advice and guess what happened? That doesn’t happen that often. And so what I’ve started doing is a little tiny practice that I’d love to offer to anybody out there listening 30s before I close my eyes at night, I think what is one small way that I added value today? And what’s one small way that I felt valued today? And I promise you that one night when I was on a book deadline, this was what I was thankful for. This is where I added value. I was in a huge parking lot up by a Sam’s Club, and I was about to get the prime spot by the exit, and I noticed a gentleman turning the corner. So excited to get that spot and just looked crushed that I had gotten it. And so I motioned for him to take the spot and I talked about. That’s how I added value that day. It was teeny tiny. It could be, you know what I call in the book? Find your traffic BFF. Be the person that always lets people in. Just that’s such an easy way to add value and to get that little. Thank you. We are, they call it the helper’s high. It gives us something, even just those small little moments so we can connect to our impact, but it takes attention to do that.
Jonathan Fields: [00:28:07] Yeah, no, I love that. And what you described with, um, Fire Chief Greg, also for anyone who’s been working in an organization, a corporate job where especially a larger company, this is not an alien feeling to them that like so often, you know, the work that you do on a daily basis is so disconnected from the eventual, from the impact, from the outcome, that it’s really hard for us to find that. So I could see somebody who is leading a team or a small group of people, um, just trying to think of like, how can I imagine in my day to day life, how can, how can I in some way, shape or form, even if I can’t connect them to that eventual big thing? Like what mechanism can I create just in our weekly gatherings where they feel that sense of I like, I can see my effort actually mattering.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:29:02] Making a few ideas for that, for that manager. So I went as part of my research. I went to a factory in Phillips, Wisconsin, uh, that was building the machines that made corrugated boxes. So these are very technical machines. Big. I don’t know how long they take to make them, but it’s quite a while. And here’s what the managers did there. They created story cards. So at each workstation where the worker was building a piece, there would be a story card that showed how the piece being made fit into the final product. And on that card was a photo and a story about the person who would one day use it. And what those story cards did was they, they signaled to the workers that they weren’t just assembling parts. They were building something meaningful that a real person was betting their livelihood on. So that is a way of connecting people to their impact. Another, uh, another thing that I’ve, I’ve found in, um, in companies that are really intentional is something that I call connecting the dots for people. So talking about who they are. So you could, you know, even if you’re, you’re, let’s say you have a colleague who is so great at planning team bonding events, you know, happy hours, great lunches. Instead of saying thank you to that person, you can connect them to their impact by, by appreciating who they are, not just what they do. So you can say to that person, you know, you really are the social glue that keeps this department together. We are so lucky to have you. So again, talking about who the person is, not just what they do for the team is another way of feeding that sense of mattering.
Jonathan Fields: [00:31:01] Yeah, that makes so much sense. And these are examples that are simple. You know, you can do this. So sure, we’re talking about this maybe in a job, but a leader, you can do this as a parent. You can do this in your local community, you know, like, like whatever organization or group, you know, that, that, that meets once a month and you’re trying to figure out like, how do we get this feeling among everybody?
Jennifer Wallace: [00:31:22] I would love to say, if you, if you are in one of those groups, a phrase that I think has an outsized impact on connecting people to their impact is if it wasn’t for you, if it wasn’t for you, um, I wouldn’t have gone for that big job interview. Thank you for believing in me when I couldn’t believe in myself. Or if it wasn’t for you, I wouldn’t. I don’t know how I would have made it through that day in the emergency room. So a small text, a little email, a card, if it wasn’t for you. That’s how we connect people to their impact.
Jonathan Fields: [00:31:57] Yeah, I love that.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:31:58] When I go and I, I give talks at corporate events. The number one question that I’m asked by everyone is, okay, how do I scale mattering? Yeah, I, I see the research. I don’t want to have to be, you know, my employees to be dependent on a fire chief named Greg, you know, who has mastered it. And, and I will tell you, you can scale mattering. I’ve seen it. I’m doing it. Mattering has key ingredients. Uh, and, um, it’s, it’s, those are levers to make people feel like they matter. Like I can tell you quickly what they are.
Jonathan Fields: [00:32:36] Yeah. Let’s walk through because I know you have a framework that kind of like really distills it down to these four things. So like, I, let’s drop into those.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:32:43] Great. So this is a framework that was validated by Gallup. We have a report coming out in October on it, but it is significance Appreciation. Feeling invested in and feeling depended on.
Jonathan Fields: [00:32:59] So let’s tease out each one of those great.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:33:00] So significance is. Um, you know, when I ask people when they felt like they mattered, it was never the big moments of life. It was never the award or the promotion. It was the small moments, what we were talking about earlier, mattering in those mundane little moments. A colleague, you know, remembering the way they liked their coffee, um, you know, checking in after a hard week. So we crave to feel significant in small moments in our life. The idea that we hold some importance in somebody else’s mind. That’s how I define significance.
Jonathan Fields: [00:33:34] I love that, by the way, before you move on to appreciated, the coffee example is is so fun because so many of us have felt that moment, you know, like I go to my same coffee shop every morning. I remember the day that I walked up to the counter and the baristas, like 16 ounce decaf almond milk latte to go cup. Right. And I was like, oh my gosh, like, you know me.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:33:58] Exactly. You know me. I’m worth remembering. Yeah. It’s a, that is such a powerful moment of mattering. Um, so, and then appreciation I’ve come to think of as appreciating the doer behind the deed. So, um, you know, it’s, it’s saying to your child’s teacher, um, you know, instead of saying, thank you so much for helping Johnny with his math, you could say, you know, you are so patient and you have such a gift with young people. And Johnny has has really never liked math until your class, you, you have really turned things around for him and I am so grateful. So again, it’s, it’s appreciating people for who they are, not just what they do. Feeling invested in is knowing that there are people in your life who are invested in your well-being and goals. In the book, I call it having a cornerman, which is a term from boxing. The guy in the corner who’s, you know, encouraging the boxer through setbacks and wiping their brow and wrapping their hands. We all know how important it is to have someone in our corner, but we rarely talk about the power of being a cornerman, of doing the investing and researchers who study mattering talk about ego extension. Uh, that’s the idea of investing. I think of it almost like visually, the idea of extending your own ego to include the egos of others so that their success feels like your success. So when we invest in people, we get that kickback of mattering. And so we don’t talk about it as much. We talk about how lucky we are to have a mentor, but we don’t talk about the gift that it is to be a mentor. And then the last one is depended on its knowing that you have people in your life who depend and rely on you, and that there are people in this world that you can rely on to. It’s what gives us that psychological safety that we’re not going through this world alone.
Jonathan Fields: [00:35:59] And we’ll be right back after a word from our sponsors. So a lot of people joining us for this conversation are going to find themselves in what’s often called their part of the sandwich generation. You know, they’re a parent who’s taking care of a kid. Maybe it’s a young kid, maybe it’s an adult kid. Um, and at the same time, they’re an adult, maybe in their 30s, 40s, 50s, 60s, who is taking care of an aging parent who is maybe reaching a point where they really need help. Talk to me about sort of like these two different applications of this framework. Like maybe simple examples. So like, let’s take these four different elements. Significance appreciated, infested and depended on and and and look at maybe the example of helping a kid with this and then helping an older parent, an aging parent.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:36:55] So I would say helping a kid. So mattering is first developed in childhood. We initially matter to our parents, that is, or we don’t. And and there’s a wonderful sociologist, Gregory Elliott at Brown who has this phrase, what gets in early gets in deep. So often when you you were earlier talking about, you know, the the business person who has all the success and all the money and all the material goods and still doesn’t feel like they matter. Often it’s sort of a core wound that we can fix. We that we can overcome that. But we have to know it’s there. So mattering in childhood is extraordinarily important. One way of making a young person feel like they matter is what I call getting a PhD in them, making them feel significant because you remember things that they like. So, for example, my mother remembers how my daughter loves what pasta shape she loves, how she loves it cooked, how she, you know, all these things, these particular things she remembers, she, she collects the this knowledge like little tiny treasures, um, and goes back to them and circles back to them. So for young people, it is, um, I honestly, I’ve been researching achievement culture for quite a long time and when it becomes toxic, um, and I think the greatest role for modern parents is to convince their children of their worth outside of a system that tells them they have to prove it and prove it over and over and over again.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:38:36] So if you can give your child that sense of unconditional love and worth, That is how we really feel, that deep sense of mattering. Um, for an older person, um, you know, asking for advice is one of the greatest. Being asked for advice is one of the greatest sources of self-esteem. So if you have a parent who is not very mobile anymore, um, might be having some cognitive decline, you can still ask for advice. They have a lifetime of advice to offer you. So ask advice. Ask them how they how they make that tomato sauce. Ask them what they would do about the garage door that keeps getting stuck. Ask them about how they would, you know, any variety of things, how they would handle a situation with your child? What would you have done, dad or mom? How would you handle it? So for the child, it is instilling the sense of unconditional worth. And for an older person it is. Asking for advice, but I would also love to address the person, the parent feeling smushed in the middle.
Jonathan Fields: [00:39:51] Yeah, yeah.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:39:52] And explain to them that this idea of mattering too much is how I call it, is where you are so essential to everyone else’s needs, but your needs are never met. That’s not true. Mattering. So true mattering is about balance. Balancing our own needs. Fulfilling our own needs with the needs of others. And I struggled for years to find that balance. Until I read a study at the Mayo Clinic that gave me some direction on it. Um, researchers were testing a simple intervention with busy medical professionals who were also mothers. They had them meet for one hour a week for 12 weeks to support each other, to feel seen and heard, like they try to do with their own kids and patients. After 12 weeks, those physicians reported higher levels of well-being, lower levels of stress. Their cortisol levels had dropped. And that’s because our resilience is rooted in the resilience of our relationships. And when we are mattering too much, it is so easy to let those relationships fall by the wayside. But that is what gives us resilience. It’s relationships that remind us that we are valued, that we matter. Making room for them in our calendars. Again, the research finds it only takes an hour a week. I happen to need more than that. But. But according to the data, you can get that sort of sense of resilience in an hour a week. So if you are listening and you feel like you matter too much, find 1 or 2 people in your life that you can open up to. You know, we’re often told as caregivers to put our oxygen mask on first. But this goes deeper. It’s, it’s having people close to you who can see when you are struggling, and who will put that mask on for you. Mhm. That’s a different level of support than we normalize.
Jonathan Fields: [00:41:44] Yeah. I mean, and part of it and tell me if I’m getting this right too, but part of what it sounds like is that we can sometimes conflate the feeling of being needed with mattering so we can be wildly needed. We can have everybody clamoring for our time, our attention, our skills, our abilities and, and give it like and give and give and give and give and give and still not have the feeling of mattering.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:42:14] Yeah. Because you are so essential to everyone else’s needs. But your needs are never met. I mean, we see this in, in educators. We see this in medical professionals, first responders. I mean, those are people that are so needed, but they need to be supported. So, you know, going back to that framework of said and those ingredients to mattering. There is one that says depended on and that’s important, but it needs to be depended on in sustainable ways. There needs to be support coupled when the stressors go up, the supports need to go up. And that’s a an idea that I got from a psychologist, Lisa Damour, she says. And I always think about it in my head when I have a really stressful time in my life, I think, oh, the stressors have gone up. That means the supports need to go up. That’s how we stay resilient.
Jonathan Fields: [00:43:09] Yeah. Let’s talk about the opposite of that then, because if we can, if the pendulum can really swing to the extreme side of everybody wanting everything from you all the time, what about that same parent? Right? Um, their kid, they’ve been really involved in their kids lives. They have a great relationship. They’ve been supportive, they’ve done great work with their kid, and their kid really feels like a sense of self-worth and like they matter just for who they are and they’re showing up and they’re out there and they’re building their own lives, and maybe they have people in their lives that are important to them and a job they really care about. And, and then like they’re in their late 20s. And then, and then you as a parent, you’re kind of like, I derive so much mattering from that. They don’t need that from me in the same way anymore or nearly as often. And I feel like I don’t matter anymore. Where do we go with that?
Jennifer Wallace: [00:44:08] So it’s interesting when people would often say to me that they didn’t feel like they mattered anymore. They were generally going through a life transition, like you’re describing either an empty nest or a lost a job, or retired or became a new parent and left the workforce. And so, you know, it’s because we matter not in a vacuum. We matter in specific ways to specific people in specific roles. And when those roles go away, our sense of mattering can deflate overnight. And so the people that I met who were able to recover well from those setbacks, who were able to get through life transitions intact, um, they generally followed two steps. Um, they, uh, you know, first they looked for role models. They looked for people like them who had gone through something similar and used their lives as a kind of blueprint for their own. So they invited them for coffee. If you don’t know somebody, you could read a memoir. You could listen to a podcast on somebody going through something similar. So find out other people who have gone through something similar and use their life as an idea on how to get through your own. And then importantly, the second step, and this can be hard when we’re going through a life transition, is to harness the power of invitation, both accepting invitations and issuing invitations.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:45:38] So often when we’re going through a painful transition, we’re hesitant to reach out because we feel like we need to get our act together. But there’s research called the Beautiful Mess Effect that I love that talks about how we overestimate how perfect we need to be, and underestimate how much our sense of vulnerability makes us good relationship partners. It makes us sticky. Um, it gives somebody something to stick to. So if you are going through a painful transition, say yes to the invitations. Say yes to them. Um, that is how we rebuild our sense of mattering. And let’s say you are there was a woman I interviewed, um, who went through a painful divorce, and she was complaining to her therapist that her social life really collapsed overnight. Many of the couples went with the husband and the therapist said, well, you have agency here. You can start inviting people into your kitchen for dinner. You can invite people in. And that’s how you can rebuild your sense of mattering. And that’s what she did. So look for role models and harness the power of invitation. Mhm.
Jonathan Fields: [00:46:45] I wonder if you found in your research also in all these conversations, people feeling like the experience of feeling like they don’t matter. And maybe let’s, let’s just build on the example of parent. You’ve done a great job, but the kids sort of like is in a great place actually, and they just don’t need you in the same way. Um, that the feeling of not mattering in that moment is a signal that something’s wrong rather than just a signal that something’s come to an end. And, and it’s, and it’s, and maybe it’s time for something new to begin.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:47:22] I totally agree with that. I think of those, you know, to feel like you don’t matter is extremely painful. So I want to first recognize that it’s very painful. I mean, the psychological pain is akin to physical pain. So I want to just normalize that for anybody going through a transition. But I think you are right. It is an invitation for us to find a new way to matter.
Jonathan Fields: [00:47:45] So somebody joining us for this conversation and nodding along saying great information, you’re naming the feeling that I have been experiencing and really opening my eyes to maybe where it’s coming from to maybe some shifts that I haven’t really owned yet. Um, I want to wake up tomorrow and feel the smallest change in this. What’s the first step in here?
Jennifer Wallace: [00:48:09] I think the first step is, um. Well, I have a few first steps.
Jonathan Fields: [00:48:15] If you’re feeling. That’s fine.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:48:17] If you’re feeling like you don’t matter, I think it is putting your coat on and walking to the grocery store and thanking the cashier and saying to her, this is a tough job. These people are so impatient and you are just so graceful in how you handle it all. So really letting someone else feel like they matter. As I was researching the book, one thing that that really struck me was the importance of mattering to ourselves. And we, particularly women, are socialized not to matter to ourselves. We are socialized to fulfill everyone else’s needs and to ignore our own. But that really can can damage our sense of mattering. And so I started this small practice. Every morning while I’m brushing my teeth, I say to myself, what is one small need that I need to fill today for myself so I can show up as my best self, for myself and for the people who are depending on me. It might be, um, a 30 minute phone call with my sister. It might be that I’m so exhausted from travel that I need to. Grandmother myself is how I think of it. Sit on a couch with a cozy blanket and a delicious book and maybe some chocolate and just spoil myself for an hour that day. So really tuning in to what you need to one small need that you can feel for yourself so that you can be that source of support for all those people who depend on you.
Jonathan Fields: [00:49:40] Mhm. I love those two different invitations, sort of depending on where you are as you join us, it feels like a good place for us to come full circle. So I have asked you this question before, but it’s been a little bit of time since. And we all change in this container of Good Life Project. If I offer up the phrase to live a good life, what comes up?
Jennifer Wallace: [00:49:59] To live a good life is to surround yourself with people who value you. Um, and in situations where you can add value. So to me, to live a good life is to feel like you matter.
Jonathan Fields: [00:50:14] Mhm. Thank you.
Jennifer Wallace: [00:50:15] Thank you.
Jonathan Fields: [00:50:17] So a few things I’m really noodling on from this conversation. One of the ones that got me, honestly, is the idea Jennifer calls mattering too much. You can be needed by a kid, an aging parent, a boss, a neighbor all at once. Giving constantly and still feel invisible. Like you don’t matter. Because being essential to everyone’s needs while your own go unmet is not actually mattering. A second is her framework. The four ingredients significance, appreciation, feeling invested in and feeling depended on. That is a really powerful diagnostic. When something feels off, you can usually name which one of those has gone quiet or completely absent. And the third is the simplest and may be most useful. Five words if it wasn’t for you. That’s how you connect somebody to an impact they can’t see from where they’re standing. So here’s maybe something to think about doing this week. Pick one person who has no idea what they did for you. Send them a text that starts with those five words. Finish the sentence with something specific, something they’d never guess you remembered. Then notice what it does for you. And hey, before you go, do me a quick favor. Think of one person in your life who maybe they’re needed by everybody, yet probably feels unseen. Maybe like they don’t really matter or matter as much as they’d love to. Send them this episode. And while you’re at it, go ahead and leave us a review. If it’s easy enough for you to do. It helps us get discovered and brings more people into the conversation. This episode of Good Life Project was produced by executive producers Lindsey Fox and me, Jonathan Fields. Editing help By Troy Young and Alejandro Ramirez. Kris Carter crafted our theme music. And of course, if you haven’t already done so, go ahead and follow us wherever you get your podcasts so you never miss a conversation. Until next time. I’m Jonathan Fields, signing off for Good Life Project.
The post How to Stop Feeling Invisible: The 4 Ingredients of Mattering | Jennifer Wallace appeared first on Good Life Project.



Bengali (Bangladesh) ·
English (United States) ·