In 1995, Drew Barrymore hopped up on David Letterman’s desk for a dance that became one of the most memorable moments in late-night TV history. Thirty years later, the endlessly charming actress has reprised her classic pop culture touchstone by climbing onto another late-night host’s desk to shimmy her hips once again, this time atop the desk of Stephen Colbert, whose show was shockingly canceled earlier this year. Days after she showed up and shook it on Late Night With Stephen Colbert, Barrymore welcomed Letterman as a guest on her own daytime program, The Drew Barrymore Show, where he offered his reflections on their infamous moment and her recent recreation.