New York Turns On Top Journalist’s 5-Word Remark as Juan Soto’s All-Star Snub Debate Resurfaces Amid Glorious Run

The September air at Citi Field carried a charge the moment Juan Soto connected. He stepped up to the plate, absolutely crushed a fastball, sending it soaring into the darkness. The crowd went wild as he made his way around the bases, the scoreboard lighting up with another stat. He’s not just on a streak—Soto’s playing like a man on a mission, putting himself on track to join a select group of players who have achieved something truly special. With a pace of around 40 home runs, 30 stolen bases, 100 RBI, 100 runs scored, and 100 walks within reach, he’s chasing numbers no hitter has reached since the early 2000s. Yet despite this dominance, a midsummer omission still hangs over his resume.

That omission? The 2025 All-Star Game, where Soto, already a three-time All-Star and World Series champion, wasn’t selected. Looking back at his stats from the first half of the season, they were solid but didn’t blow anyone away: .265 average, 16 home runs, 48 RBI, .850 OPS. By midsummer standards, those numbers didn’t scream “automatic lock,” especially in a National League rich with outfield talent. But the second half has been a different story. Soto has gone on a tear, lifting his OPS to .951, and launching homers at a career-best pace. The gap between July’s snub and September’s brilliance has become impossible to ignore.

“Not an All-Star this year,” veteran New York journalist Jon Heyman wrote on X, quote-tweeting the breakdown of Juan Soto’s projected milestones. The bluntness of his five words cut straight to the irony; a season that now looks historic didn’t come with the league’s most basic stamp of mid-season recognition.

Not an All-Star this year https://t.co/FxwAUlp9DD

— Jon Heyman (@JonHeyman) September 2, 2025

Some took Heyman’s remark as a spotlight on how broken the midsummer classic has become. The voting process, influenced heavily by fan ballots and early narratives, left out a player now chasing numbers unseen in more than two decades. Others saw it as unnecessary snark, arguing that Soto had already silenced critics by anchoring the Mets’ playoff push with a league-leading 108 walks and a top-five on-base percentage.

Juan Soto himself hasn’t entertained the noise. Instead, he’s let his bat carry the argument. Since the break, he’s hit .312 with a 1.014 OPS, stolen bases with ease, and carried the Mets into the thick of the playoff race. Every swing, every sprint makes the All-Star snub look more absurd in hindsight. And thanks to Heyman’s five-word reminder, the debate has been reignited, not as a footnote, but as a defining talking point in what could be remembered as one of Soto’s greatest seasons.

Social media turns Juan Soto’s snub into a flashpoint

Heyman’s five-word reminder didn’t just slip past unnoticed; it set off sparks. The moment his post hit X, the comment section turned into a debate hall. Mets fans jumped in to defend their star, while others treated it as proof that the All-Star voting system is more about popularity than performance. Some even accused Heyman of stirring the pot just for effect. What started as a blunt take quickly turned into a full-blown argument, every side convinced that they had the right word.

One fan fired back at Heyman by pointing out the case of Nathan Eovaldi, noting that Juan Soto wasn’t the only star overlooked. “Neither was Nathan Eovaldi, who led the league in ERA and WHIP at the time, but was snubbed. Didn’t see you bit*hing about that,” the fan wrote, accusing Heyman of selective outrage. The frustration isn’t baseless. Eovaldi entered the 2025 All-Star break with a sparkling 2.61 ERA and a league-best 0.98 WHIP, yet somehow didn’t crack the roster. To that fan, Heyman’s silence back then made his sudden spotlight on Soto feel inconsistent, as if the journalist chose drama over balance. It’s a reminder that All-Star snubs don’t happen in isolation, and fans rarely forget who gets left out.

Another fan cut even deeper, accusing Heyman of bias by writing, “You really are a shill for Boras. No wonder you got so mad when @Keith_McPherson called you out on it.” The dig goes beyond Soto’s snub; it ties into a long-running perception that Heyman, who often breaks news on Scott Boras clients, gives favorable coverage to the super-agent’s players. Keith McPherson, a YES Network personality, has previously needled Heyman over that connection, and this fan seized on it to suggest his Juan Soto commentary was less about fairness and more about narrative-building. In New York’s unforgiving media ecosystem, even a five-word remark can get reframed as proof of hidden loyalties.

One reply brought history into the mix, writing, “Chipper won an MVP without being an All-Star.” The commenter referenced Chipper Jones’ 1999 season when the Braves legend missed the midsummer classic yet won NL MVP after slashing .319/.441/.633 with 45 homers and 110 RBI. The reminder underscored how flawed midseason selections can look once the full season unfolds.

Another fan focused on the format itself, saying, “All-Stars really should be after the season ends and should not be a popularity contest.” The frustration isn’t new; players and analysts have long criticized the midseason voting as rewarding name recognition over full-season excellence. In 2015, Royals manager Ned Yost admitted the process was “a little bit of a popularity contest” after Kansas City fans nearly voted in eight starters despite underwhelming stats. More recently, in 2023, Freddie Freeman questioned the snub of teammate Will Smith, calling him “the best catcher in baseball,” despite fan voting leaving Smith off the initial roster. Soto’s case feels like déjà vu; his second-half surge has made his earlier omission Exhibit A for why midseason ballots often miss the bigger picture.

In the end, Heyman’s five-word reminder did more than stir debate; it exposed cracks in MLB’s midseason honor system. Juan Soto’s historic run turned a snub into a spotlight, forcing fans to question the process itself. And as his numbers climb, the conversation shows no sign of fading.

The post New York Turns On Top Journalist’s 5-Word Remark as Juan Soto’s All-Star Snub Debate Resurfaces Amid Glorious Run appeared first on EssentiallySports.